Academy » Costs and Productivity

Costs and Productivity — Lesson 2: Downtime: How Much an Hour of a Stopped Machine Really Costs and How to Calculate It

Costs and Productivity · 4 min read · 17.11.2026

Why most companies underestimate downtime

Welcome to the second lesson of the Costs and Productivity series. Last time we covered OEE and showed that a single number only tells part of the truth about a line. Today we'll look at something OEE includes but doesn't put a price tag on: downtime. You'll calculate how much an hour of a stopped machine really costs — and understand why most production managers underestimate that number.

When we ask foremen on projects how much an hour of a stopped machine costs them, the answer is almost always the same: "the hourly rate from the costing." Typically €30–50/h. But that's just the tariff cost — machine, energy, personnel.

This figure tells you how much the machine costs you when it's running. It doesn't tell you how much you lose when it's stopped. If the machine is the bottleneck of the workshop and it stops, it produces nothing you can sell. The real loss is much higher than the rate.

A stopped machine doesn't cut into your costs. It cuts into your revenue.

How to calculate the real cost of an hour of downtime

We use a formula a foreman can handle on a whiteboard in five minutes:

Cost of downtime = gross margin rate of hourly output × hourly production

Step by step:

  1. Find out how many finished pieces the machine (or the line where the machine is the bottleneck) produces per hour. For example, 120 pieces/h.
  2. Find out the margin per piece. For example, €4.
  3. Multiply: 120 × 4 = €480 per hour. That's what you actually fail to produce during an hour of downtime.
  4. Compare with the tariff rate. The difference between €480 and €40 is also the difference between how the workshop perceives downtime and how accounting does.

For machines that aren't the bottleneck, a different rule applies. When a process has slack capacity and you can catch up on lost production with overtime or a faster pace, the loss approaches the tariff rate. So the first question for every machine is: is it the bottleneck, or not? If yes, calculate by margin. If not, calculate by rate — and manage the buffers in between.

Hidden downtime nobody records

In companies with 50–300 employees, we keep seeing the same picture. Downtime records capture only major events — a breakdown, a mold change, missing material. Short stoppages under 5 minutes go unaddressed. Yet those cause the biggest damage. There are many of them, and nobody adds them up.

At one engineering company (metalworking, 120 employees), we measured three shifts on a CNC Wire EDM. Official downtime: 48 minutes per shift. Time studies showed 137 minutes. The difference — 89 minutes per day — was 80 % made up of small stoppages: waiting for inspection, searching for a fixture, minor cleaning. At an hourly loss of €320, this amounted to roughly €474 per day on a single machine, over €100,000 per year. Nobody had put a number on it, because it didn't fit into the "downtime" column.

Here's how to get data instead of estimates:

  • Measure diligently for a week on key machines — with a stopwatch, or at least 2 days of manual observation.
  • Add categories to the record: breakdown, changeover, missing material, waiting for quality, minor stoppages.
  • Multiply the times by category by the cost of downtime from the formula above. You'll get a ranking in €, not by gut feeling.

The ranking by money is key. Team leaders often tackle what's loud, not what's expensive. When they have values in euros on the whiteboard, prioritization takes care of itself.

This week's exercise

Pick one key machine — ideally one you suspect is the workshop's bottleneck. Do three things:

  1. Calculate the cost of an hour of downtime using the formula (pieces/h × margin/piece).
  2. Measure all stoppages over two shifts, including those under 5 minutes. Record the reason and duration.
  3. Announce the result at the production meeting: how many € per day the machine is really "eating" and which category is the most expensive.

You don't have to fix anything right away. The number itself usually sparks a discussion that never happened before.

Key takeaways

  • The tariff rate tells you how much the machine costs; the margin-based output tells you how much you lose when it's stopped.
  • For a bottleneck, calculate the cost of downtime as pieces/h × margin/piece, not by the costing rate.
  • Short stoppages under 5 minutes mostly go unnoticed — they're precisely the biggest hidden loss.
  • Prioritize downtime by €, not by how loud the problem is.

If you want to calculate the hourly cost of downtime for an entire line, check out the other lessons in our online course on costs and production.

In the next lesson, we'll move on to the bottleneck — the single workstation that determines the output of the entire workshop and to which you adjust the pace of all the others.


Quiz — test your knowledge


« Lesson 1

« Back to the academy